Insurance in Estes Park starts with the place. A mountain home with long winters, wildlife in the yard and a well out back is not the same file as a house in a Front Range suburb, and a lot of properties here are short-term rentals or second homes.
Three agencies is a short list, so call all three and ask the same questions. Tell them if the place is a rental or sits empty half the year. I would rather hear an agent say what a policy will not cover now than find out later.
Around the valley
Susan Fereday's State Farm office is on St Vrain Lane near the fairgrounds, next to Elkhorn Law and a short walk from Ziggi's Coffee. Home and auto are the bread and butter, and those two policies are what most people come in about.
Near the Events Complex on Community Drive, next to Lake Pines Self Storage, the Danielle D Arnold Agency is the American Family Insurance office in Estes Park. Danielle Arnold is the agent, licensed in Colorado, and Jeremy Arnold works alongside her as a sales specialist across all lines.
Home and auto, renters, boat and motorcycle, life, health, Medicare and travel all run through this one office on South St. Vrain, in the same building as Fanciful Floral and Third One Barber Shop.
Try another filter, or show every insurance agencies again.
Map tiles could not load.
Map tiles © OpenStreetMap contributors
Only three agencies on this page are listed, and all three have an office in the valley. Susan Fereday writes State Farm policies and is licensed in Colorado and Wyoming. The Danielle D Arnold Agency is the American Family Insurance office in town. Kyle Insurance Group is an independent local agency that covers personal lines, Medicare, health, business and boats.
Agents who write for one carrier can only quote that carrier. That can be fine if you already like the company, but if you want to compare, ask each office what it can and cannot place. Kyle Insurance Group lists free consultations and help with claims and with understanding a policy, which is a useful question to ask every agent.
If you own a rental or a cabin you only visit part of the year, say so up front. Ask how the policy treats time the property sits empty, guests who pay to stay there, and any business coverage you need. Agents can only answer what they are asked, and surprises on a claim are costly. It also helps to ask how each office handles claims and who you call after hours.
Yes. This page lists three agencies with offices in the valley: Susan Fereday of State Farm, the Danielle D Arnold Agency for American Family Insurance, and Kyle Insurance Group. Each covers auto and home, and the offices differ on health and Medicare lines.
Kyle Insurance Group lists Medicare and health coverage alongside its auto, home, life and business lines. Susan Fereday's State Farm office also lists health coverage. Call ahead to ask which plans each office can actually place.
All three agencies list business coverage. Kyle Insurance Group also lists commercial coverage and workers' compensation through the same office. Ask what is covered for seasonal operations, since many Estes Park businesses cut hours or close in winter.
Susan Fereday's State Farm office lists recreational vehicle and boat policies, and Kyle Insurance Group lists boat and motorcycle coverage. If you have something else that is heavy on adventure, call and ask before assuming it is included.
